Twelve people addressed a crowded Nettle Creek Schools board meeting Nov. 10 on behalf of Hagerstown High School teacher Jason Schmittler. They expressed concern that the English teacher and cross-country coach could face termination.

Echoing recent social media exchanges and speculation, speakers said that Schmittler attempted to de-escalate a physical altercation at a school athletic event in September. Those speaking said Schmittler was suspended after physically removing one student from the other, and that despite returning to the classroom since, they think his continued employment remains under review. 

WWN has been unable to confirm the nature of the incident or the school district’s response, including any changes in Schmittler’s status. Schmittler has not returned a request for comment as of press time. School officials have not issued a public statement, and declined to speak with WWN about the matter, citing personnel privacy.

Board member Marcie Houghton speaks during the Nov. 10 meeting. Houghton’s son was involved in a September incident prompting community concern. Photos by Lorin Williams

Schmittler’s mother, Sally, said she felt the pursuit of punishment was blown out of proportion, echoing the statements “Justice for Schmitty” and “fair treatment” that had been shared on social media. Schmittler’s brother, Tracy, said Schmittler acted to prevent something more violent from occurring and that “reprimanding him is ridiculous.”

Other speakers addressed Schmittler’s character and dedication to students.

Board member Marcie Houghton acknowledged that her son was involved in the incident. Without providing specifics of what happened, she defended the board and Superintendent Emily Schaeffer for the difficult task of responding, saying that she understands safety is a top priority. 

Houghton said she had spoken with Schmittler about the incident to address what happened, that she understands his actions, and that there is no remaining ill will from her or her son. She addressed unfounded social media postings that led to “severe mental anguish and harassment” for her family and son. 

Another parent of a student involved, Amanda Stout, said her son had moved on and accepted the consequences. She said the incident was nothing more than “kids being kids.”

Board members Mike Banning and Ruthie LaMar said they appreciated the public’s attendance and asked for confidence in the board’s leadership and process. Board members Sandi Schraub and Cody Sankey expressed disappointment about the difficult comments that Houghton described receiving.

As of Nov. 16, Schmittler remains listed as a teacher on the Nettle Creek Schools website.

Teacher contract agreement

In other business, the board held a public hearing to address details of the tentative agreement between the Nettle Creek School Corporation and the Nettle Creek Classroom Teachers Association. The current proposal received a 22-19 approval vote from the association, with a final vote set for Friday, Nov. 13. 

Teacher Tina Bane responded on behalf of the NCCTA and described transparency issues throughout the process. Next year, they request to start negotiations earlier for a more collaborative and successful process for both parties. The public hearing was closed. 

Business manager Amber Rushton noted stable finances and a cash balance increase. Reduction in education fund expenditures was due to not transferring $115K to the operations fund for the rest of the year.

In school news, kindergarten teacher Christina Neuman was this month’s “Heart of the Tiger” recipient; a veterans program was held Nov. 11; and sixth and third graders enjoyed field trips. Art teacher Beth Overfield was the Jr./Sr. high school staff of the month and four students were acknowledged as Lilly Scholarship finalists. The cheer team finished second in a state competition and a chili fundraiser was held Nov. 12. 

Claims, payroll, a personnel report and a new copier lease were approved, along with the first reading of employee job descriptions and second readings of several board policies. The adoption of an amendment to an Oct. 1 disciplinary letter to reflect administrative leave with pay was approved.

Schaeffer noted NCSC did not meet statutory requirements concerning 2026 teacher compensation and funding floor, per the Indiana Department of Education. IDOE mandates at least 65% of state tuition be expended on teacher compensation. Administration will seek clarification from the IDOE.

The next board meeting will be Tuesday, Dec. 8, at 6:30 p.m. in the elementary school’s LGI Room, 299 N. Sycamore St. The public may attend.

Share this:

A version of this article appeared in the November 18 2026 print edition of the Western Wayne News.

Lorin Williams is a reporter for the Western Wayne News.